How Credit Counseling and Debt Management Plans Work: What the Standard Explanation Leaves Out

For those struggling with unsecured debt, several options exist to get balances under control and work towards full repayment. One such option is a debt management plan (DMP), in which clients work with a credit counseling agency to consolidate and repay their loans, typically over 48 to 60 months. DMPs allow consumers to work down debts with a single lower-interest monthly payment, which is often easier to track than a collection of smaller, unconnected installments.

While DMPs are undoubtedly useful in the right situations, the standard explanation of their mechanisms sometimes leaves out important information. This guide will examine the functions, costs, and benefits of DMPs to help you decide if it’s the right debt resolution tool for your situation.

What Actually Happens at Intake and Enrollment

After a consumer contacts a credit counseling agency, they’ll participate in intake and enrollment sessions to assess their debt and make initial DMP decisions. Budget assessments are a large part of these early sessions; because a DMP requires a consumer to have enough income to cover their expenses and the new monthly payment, a budget review might show a client can’t handle a DMP in the first conversation. After assessing a client’s budget and deciding to move forward with a DMP, the credit counselor will contact the client’s creditors to lock in the terms of the plan.

It’s important to know that creditors have infrastructure in place for deciding DMP terms. When counselors contact creditors to decide terms, they only select rates and concessions from an existing list, rather than negotiating a bespoke agreement on a case-by-case basis. Once terms are decided with all creditors, the consumer usually pays a one-time enrollment fee, and the payments begin. Consumers will also usually have to close out relevant credit accounts before the plan begins.

How the Concession Rate is Actually Set

Where a DMP Genuinely Helps

The primary benefits of DMPs lie in their consolidated nature. Rather than tracking a number of interest rates and payment dates, DMPs allow consumers to make a single, predictable, and repeated payment to a single source that addresses all of their debts simultaneously. DMPs also usually involve a lower interest rate than the original debt, typically down to a concession in the 6 to 13% range from a card's original APR, and carry a pre-set end date, usually 48 to 60 months out. For a consumer with a steady, comfortable budget, that combination is genuinely useful: one payment replaces several, the rate is meaningfully lower than what they were paying before, collectors generally stop contacting them directly while they stay current, and there's a fixed date by which the entire balance, not just a portion of it, is scheduled to be gone. For the right consumer, that lowered interest rate and defined finish line can provide the necessary foundation for paying off debt.

What the Standard Explanation Leaves Out

Alongside their many advantages, there are certain aspects of DMPs that are often excluded from overviews of the tool. Firstly, as mentioned, creditors maintain standing structures for reducing interest rates and selecting payment terms; this means the structure of a DMP is based wholly on what the consumer’s budget can handle, rather than how successfully a counselor can negotiate a good rate.

It’s also important for consumers to understand the relationship between counselor income and DMPs. Creditors pay a portion of consumer payments back to the counseling agency, which sets a financial incentive for counselors to place consumers on DMPs. These “fair share” repayments make up roughly 72% of agency revenue. An IRS report found that, over time, credit counseling agencies have become "mere sellers of debt-management plans," "motivated primarily by profit". Since that profit runs largely through DMP enrollment, it's worth knowing your options going into a consultation.

Not Always An Advantage

While a single, recurring, unadjusted payment can provide the security and predictability that some consumers need, this inflexibility can also pose a danger. If a consumer’s financial situation changes after committing to the DMP, the monthly payment doesn’t change, which is a major driver of DMP dropouts.

Dropping out of a DMP also carries its own costs; counselor fees are non-refundable, and balances revert to their original APRs, which can make it more expensive to drop out than to finish the plan. Therefore, it’s crucial for a consumer to secure a reliable, steady income that is unlikely to change before locking into a DMP.

Who a DMP Actually Fits

The most important qualifying factor for a DMP is a comfortable, steady income, specifically, one that can comfortably absorb a payment well above the minimums the consumer was making before, and sustain it for 4 to 5 years. Clearer payments and lower interest rates are likely to sound attractive to a majority of those struggling with debt, but a DMP is primarily an administrative solution, not a financial one. A DMP is best for a consumer with spread-out, unsecured debt and a budget that allows repayment at that higher level.

What a DMP Genuinely Offers vs. What It Costs

Questions Worth Asking Before Enrolling

Understanding your relationship to a potential counseling agency before committing is always worthwhile. One important question is if the relationship would be fiduciary, which means the agency is legally required to put client interests ahead of its own. Credit counseling agencies are not bound by a fiduciary standard, and are subject to financial incentives that might make some services more profitable than others. This is often not disclosed to customers, leading them to assume credit counseling agencies are motivated by effective outcomes, are conducting detailed negotiations with creditors, and are therefore hearing impartial advice about all their options, including the lowest-cost ones. While they are not fiduciaries, ethical standards are set for credit counseling agencies by the National Foundation for Credit Counseling.

When discussing profitability for counseling agencies, it’s useful to understand nonprofit status as a tax designation. Many credit counseling agencies are labelled as nonprofit organizations, which does carry an implied focus on education and debt resolution, but these groups are still profit-oriented and follow financial incentives. This doesn't mean credit counseling is unsound or unwise; it means how these agencies are actually funded creates a financial incentive worth understanding before you enroll, one that exists alongside whatever real help the service provides.

How to Read a DMP Offer Accurately

Once terms have been established, a consumer will receive a DMP offer. This document is often dense and detailed, so it’s important to know what figures to look for before enrolling.

• Monthly payment: Most critically, ensure you understand the amount you’ll be paying to the credit counselor each month. Ensure this figure fits within your current budget and will continue to be feasible until the end of your DMP.
• Agency fees: Watch for enrollment fees and monthly administrative charges from the credit agency. Make sure these additional payments won’t make you unable to complete your plan.
• Creditor concessions: Creditors often lower interest rates when a consumer's debt is put into a DMP, commonly into the 6 to 13% range. Tracking those reduced rates is a big part of understanding a DMP offer.
• Included debts: Checking that all expected unsecured debts are present in the payment plan will prevent accidental missed payments if one was left out.
• Estimated plan completion: Check the date that the plan is scheduled to complete. The same payment will be due each month across this period, but, once completed, all of the involved debts will be paid off.

FAQs

Is a debt management plan ever a good option? 

Yes, a DMP can be a good option for someone with a budget that can sustain a single higher monthly payment with a lower interest rate. It's a poor fit for a tight budget given the total cost and length, as it requires consistent payments over a long period.

Does the credit counselor negotiate my rate for me? 

Not in the traditional sense. Creditors set fixed concession bands, and the agency requests a tier based on the payment your budget supports. This number will be based on your personal budget, but the agency will only select profitable terms from a menu, rather than fighting to get clients the best rate they can.

Is my credit counselor a fiduciary, or required to give impartial advice? 

Generally, credit counselors are not fiduciaries. Credit counseling agencies aren't held to a fiduciary standard, and their funding model is based on receiving a share of client payments back from creditors. This creates a structural incentive worth understanding: the agency's revenue depends in part on the same DMP it's recommending.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, a DMP provides a route to clarification and debt consolidation, but it carries costs and functions that are often left out of agency explanations. DMPs are only suitable for consumers with the resources to make a regular monthly payment alongside their existing expenses and agency administrative fees. DMPs generate ongoing revenue for the agency in a way other debt resolution options don't, so it's worth remembering they have a financial incentive to recommend one. A full understanding of the structure’s benefits and drawbacks is the best way to decide if a DMP is best for you.

References